The Multivariate Harmony Equation: A Project-Based Learning Case Study for the “Statistics and Probability” Unit in Secondary Mathematics Using Local Social Data

Amir Iskandar bin Abdullah   [Malaysia]

Abstract

The “Statistics and Probability” unit within Malaysia's secondary mathematics curriculum is frequently perceived as abstract and tedious due to its detachment from real-world contexts. This study designed and implemented a project-based learning case titled “Multicultural Harmony Equation”, aiming to integrate the acquisition of mathematical statistical skills with an understanding of the national core issue of multicultural social harmony. The project centred on the core driving question: “Investigating the characteristics and influencing factors of social interaction networks among students in our school”. Students formed groups to design questionnaires, collect data on friendship selection, extracurricular participation, and festive celebration habits, construct and analyse ‘social network diagrams’, calculate frequencies and probabilities of various connections, and utilise chi-square tests to analyse group differences. This culminated in a ‘Multicultural Harmony Index Report for Our School’. The case embedded mathematical knowledge (data collection, graphical representation, probability calculation, preliminary statistical testing) within authentic, meaningful social inquiry. Practice demonstrates that this project significantly enhances students' intrinsic motivation for learning statistics, fosters their recognition of mathematics' practical value, and cultivates critical thinking, cross-cultural understanding, and data-driven reflection on the national concept of ‘multicultural harmony’ through data interpretation. This achieves an organic integration of mathematics education and civic education.

Keywords: Project-based learning; Statistics and Probability; Mathematics Education; Multiculturalism; Social Network Analysis; Data Literacy; Malaysian Secondary Schools

Introduction

Malaysia is a nation characterised by its distinct racial, religious, and cultural diversity, with ‘promoting national unity’ serving as a longstanding core objective of its educational policy. However, within secondary mathematics classrooms, particularly in units such as ‘Statistics and Probability’ which possess significant application potential, teaching content is often confined to abstract numerical operations and fictional examples (e.g., ball draws, dice rolls), resulting in a severe disconnect from students' lived experiences and the social realities they inhabit. This results in students who can solve problems yet struggle to grasp mathematics' value as a powerful tool for understanding society and analysing issues. They are further unable to deepen their comprehension of national circumstances through mathematical learning. Project-Based Learning (PBL) emphasises acquiring knowledge and skills through extended, interdisciplinary, real-world problem-based inquiry. Introducing PBL into mathematics' ‘Statistics and Probability’ teaching, particularly within Malaysia's multicultural context, holds significant potential. This study proposes the ‘Equations of Pluralistic Harmony’ project, using the micro-social environment most familiar to students—the school campus—as a ‘field site’. It guides them to employ statistical tools to investigate their own social networks. This not only contextualises and humanises mathematical learning but also translates the grand theme of ‘pluralistic harmony’ into observable, measurable, and analysable concrete problems. Through collecting and analysing data on friendship patterns and cultural exchanges, students not only solidify their grasp of statistical knowledge but also develop a rational, data-driven perspective for reflecting on social interactions. This fosters an understanding of both differences and commonalities, thereby subtly integrating national unity education into the mathematics classroom. This paper aims to systematically elaborate on the project's design and implementation, offering an innovative model for integrating STEM education with civic education in Malaysia.

I. Context and Theoretical Framework of the Teaching Case Design

1. Curriculum Analysis: Covers core topics in Statistics and Probability for Malaysian upper secondary mathematics (Form 4/5): data collection and presentation, measures of central tendency and dispersion, probability calculations, introductory correlation and regression, chi-square tests, etc.

2. Student Profile Analysis: Pupils possess foundational algebraic and graphical literacy, direct experience with social media and interpersonal dynamics, and awareness of racial/cultural issues though potentially lacking analytical tools for deeper reflection.

3. Theoretical Framework: Project-based learning, authentic learning, sociocultural theory, data literacy education, intercultural education.

II. Implementation Process (Three-Week Duration)

Phase One: Project Launch and Problem Definition (1-2 lessons)

1. Contextual Introduction: Present macro-level statistics on Malaysia's demographic composition and festival celebrations. Discuss ‘What constitutes social harmony? Can it be measured?’ to introduce the core question: ‘As our campus mirrors broader society, what patterns of interaction reflect its state of pluralistic harmony?’

2. Problem Statement: Each mixed-group team (ensuring racial and gender diversity) is tasked with conducting research to produce an ‘Analysis Report on Characteristics and Influencing Factors of Student Social Interaction Networks in Our School,’ and to formulate ‘mathematical recommendations’ for enhancing cross-group communication.

3. Knowledge Scaffolding: The teacher briefly reviews the fundamental steps of statistical surveys (identifying variables, designing tools, collecting data, analysing, presenting) and introduces basic concepts of ‘social network analysis’ (nodes, edges, strong ties, weak ties).

Phase Two: Scheme Design and Data Collection (Extracurricular + 2 Lesson Periods)

Research Design: Through group discussion, determine research focus, e.g.: ‘Does the type of extracurricular activities participated in by students of different races influence the number of their cross-racial friendships?’ or ‘The relationship between social media usage habits and the probability of offline cross-group communication.’

Tool Development: Under teacher guidance, design a brief anonymous questionnaire. This must include: demographic variables (ethnicity, gender, year group); social network variables (listing 3-5 closest friends and their backgrounds); behavioural variables (participation in clubs/activities, observance of festivals); and attitudinal variables (willingness to engage in cross-cultural interaction, using Likert scales).

Data Collection: Subject to ethical approval (school and parental informed consent, emphasising anonymity and voluntary participation), each group distributes and collects electronic or paper questionnaires within designated year groups or across the entire school.

Phase Three: Data Analysis and Mathematical Modelling (3-4 lessons)

This phase involves the deep application of mathematical knowledge, with students working as ‘data scientists’.

1. Data Organisation and Visualisation:

Organise data using spreadsheets.

Charting: Use pie charts to display racial distribution among friends; employ bar charts to compare participation numbers across different groups in various activities; attempt simple social network diagrams (e.g., using node colours to represent different races).

2. Statistical Analysis:

Descriptive Statistics: Calculate means, medians, and proportions of cross-racial friendships across groups.

Probability Calculations: Based on sample data, calculate probabilities such as ‘the chance of randomly encountering a student with at least one cross-racial friend’ or ‘the probability a student in a multicultural society has cross-racial friends.’

Exploring Associations (Optional/Advanced): Learn to use chi-square tests to analyse whether ‘ethnicity’ and ‘having cross-racial close friends’ are independent variables. Alternatively, calculate the correlation coefficient between ‘frequency of participation in sports activities’ and ‘number of cross-racial friends’.

3. Report Writing: Guide students to organise their analytical process and findings into a report, including: Introduction, Methods, Data Analysis Results (combining charts and text), Discussion (interpretation of results, linking to ‘multicultural harmony’), Limitations, Recommendations.

Phase Four: Presentation, Review and Reflection (2 lessons)

1. Findings Presentation: Simulate a ‘Social Studies Symposium’ where each group presents their report. Invite the Headteacher, form tutors, and PTA representatives as audience and judges.

2. Deliberation and Reflection: Focused discussion: What patterns emerge from the data regarding our school's social interaction models? Which factors appear to promote cross-group communication? Were any findings unexpected? What biases exist in our research (e.g., sampling bias, social desirability bias)? How does this affect our conclusions? Based on the data, what actionable recommendations can we propose to the school (e.g., organising specific types of mixed-group activities)?

3. Project Summary: The teacher summarises core mathematical concepts employed throughout the project and elevates the theme: Mathematics is not merely formulas, but a tool for understanding society, building dialogue, and fostering harmony.

III. Analysis and Reflection on Teaching Outcomes

Through evaluating students' research proposals, data analysis processes, final reports, reflective journals, and pre/post surveys on mathematical attitudes and intercultural cognition, this project achieved the following outcomes:

1. Dual Enhancement of Mathematical Motivation and Application Skills: Students commonly reported ‘realising for the first time how useful statistics can be’ and ‘actively learning about chi-squared tests to resolve our research questions’. Mathematical knowledge transformed from an academic objective into a problem-solving tool.

2. Cultivation of Data Literacy and Critical Thinking: While processing real, messy data, students gained profound insight into the arduousness of data collection and the critical importance of data quality. They learned to interpret data cautiously, recognising that correlation does not imply causation.

3. Deepening Rational Understanding of Diversity and Harmony: The project transformed abstract social concepts into tangible, perceptible data. One student reflected: ‘The data showed that joining a sports team together is one of the most effective ways to break down barriers – far more persuasive than any lecture. Our group's report recommended the school organise more cross-class, cross-ethnic sports leagues.’

4. Challenges and Reflections: Firstly, the project demands considerable time, necessitating careful scheduling of both lesson time and extracurricular hours. Secondly, involving sensitive demographic variables requires strict adherence to research ethics, ensuring anonymity, voluntary participation, and fostering a safe, respectful classroom environment. Finally, students' data analysis skills vary significantly, requiring teachers to provide differentiated guidance and prepare supportive tools (such as basic statistical software or online platforms).

Conclusion

The ‘Equation for Diversity and Harmony’ PBL case study successfully transformed secondary mathematics teaching of the ‘Statistics and Probability’ unit from problem-solving drills to inquiry-based practice grounded in authentic local issues. It innovatively integrates mathematical skill acquisition with Malaysia's core national education agenda. By applying mathematical knowledge to analyse their own social networks, students not only master statistical methods but also develop rational analytical skills for social phenomena, evidence-based communication abilities, and an empirical understanding of the nation's multicultural fabric. This project demonstrates that mathematics education can and should fulfil richer educational functions, offering an innovative and effective pedagogical pathway for cultivating a new generation of Malaysian citizens equipped with data literacy, rational thinking, social awareness, and national identity. This model can be adaptively applied to mathematical investigations of other social issues (such as environmental data or consumer behaviour).

References

[1] Curriculum Development Division, Ministry of Education Malaysia. (2016). Curriculum Standards and Assessment Document for Mathematics, Levels 4 & 5. Ministry of Education Malaysia.

[2]Thomas, J. W. (2000). A review of research on project-based learning. The Autodesk Foundation.

[3]Malaysian Ministry of National Unity. (2021). Research Report on the Malaysian National Unity Index. PERPADUAN.

[4]Wasserman, S., & Faust, K. (1994). Social network analysis: Methods and applications. Cambridge University Press.

[5]Boaler, J. (2016). Mathematical mindsets: Unleashing students' potential through creative math, inspiring messages and innovative teaching. Jossey-Bass.

[6] Lin Guo Rong University of Creative Technology, Faculty of Social Sciences. (2020). Briefing Paper on Malaysian Youth Social Interaction Patterns.

[7] Gould, R. (2017). Data literacy for everyone. W.H. Freeman and Company. [8] Ministry of Education, Malaysia. (2013). Malaysia Education Blueprint 2013-2025. KPM.